Well Flo, here is my opinion if you want it:
Max is out, there is no doubt about his behaviour. It is not just one incident.
Steeyk can get a second chance in my opinion. There is reason to accept he was not he one who abused admin rights. If he did abuse those rights it was possibly a 'weak moment' and he will know better from now on. Like I said before, I did not see him behave this way before (my experience) and if someone did see it that person should speak up now. I know I lost patience with players before too, it's the human condition but we should be disciplined about it.
We should all learn from this that we DO NOT give admin pass to outsiders. If you make a mistake in chat (happened to me before) just tell it to Snowman so he can decide if the PW should be changed, also make a note who was playing at that moment.
BTW Flo don't blame yourself for sometimes making a wrong judgement on people, it's those people shaming your trust who are to blame, not the one who gives the trust. And it's all part of a clan, this stuff simply happens every now and then and is all part of the game.
P.S. It wasn't me that day, I couldn't join, I know nothing, I see nothing, I hear nothing...